In Regina cold case trial, accused killer's ex-wife says she was asked to help move body
The murder trial for Joseph Thauberger resumed Thursday, with testimony from his then wife Barbara Hayes.
Thauberger stands accused of killing his brother, who was reported missing to police in 1997.
Hayes took the stand for the Crown, telling the court the events she remembered from Sept. 3 1997.
Hayes said she ran a daycare in the basement of 2721 Francis St., where she and the accused lived at the time.
On the day of the alleged incident, she said she was taking care of five children.
“I did notice James and Pat and Joe in the driveway, the windows were very large and high, they were talking. James left, Pat and Joe came in the house, went upstairs,” she told the courtroom. She believed that James was dropping Patrick off so he could take him back to the bus stop.
She remembered carrying on with the children, and at about lunchtime, she went upstairs to get something from the cupboard, and saw Patrick reclining on the couch with his arm on the back.
“We waved and said hi to each other,” she recalled.
She then testified that she went back downstairs, to take care of the children, and 10 minutes later heard a “tremendous crash, like an elephant was going to come through the ceiling.”
Hayes told court the children all looked up and asked what the noise was. She said she heard Patrick saying, ‘No, no, no.’
“I heard it very plainly, it seemed loud to me,” she said.
She said she waited 30 seconds then went up to the basement door, which was locke, something she recalled never occurred in her house before.
Hayes testified to banging on the door and asking Joseph Thauberger, “What have you done?” To which she said he responded, “Go back downstairs.”
She said she remembers waiting no more than a couple minutes before returning downstairs to care for the children.
Hayes testified that she remained in the basement for the rest of the day. She didn’t recall when the children left but remembers around the time it got dark, 8:30 p.m. she estimates, Joseph called for her.
She described him as looking like he was ready to go to the farm, with a plaid jacket and rubber boots.
"He asked me if I could help him move him,” she told the Crown. The lawyer asked, ‘Who, Pat?”
“That’s who he meant,” she said.
“Maybe I said no, maybe it was just my inside voice that said no, I just stood at the bottom of the stairs,” she told the courtroom.
She testified saying there was a blue carpet that was rolled up at the top of the stairs, and believed Patrick’s body was wrapped in the rolled up carpet.
Hayes added that Joseph had a hard time moving the carpet and testified she never saw the carpet again.
She said she went upstairs to make sure Joseph did not hit the railing, then went back downstairs.
Though the timeline she recalled was fuzzy as she stated, the occurrence of events she is sure of.
During her testimony, she said she finally went upstairs later in the night, tired and wanting sleep. She saw the cupboard door that had a gash in it that wasn’t there before and saw shoe skid marks on the floor of the kitchen.
She cannot recall when Joseph came back and what day they spoke again.
The home of Joseph Thauberger, 2721 Francis St. (Gareth Dillistone)
Later in cross-examination, Hayes said she thought maybe the crash had happened in the kitchen, since she saw the gash in the cupboard door and saw the shoe marks in the kitchen.
However, now looking at it, she is not certain it happened in the kitchen, and cannot confirm where the crash happened.
Hayes testified to a conversation in the days following, probably in the afternoon, in the kitchen where she and Joseph spoke about the incident.
She said she asked him why and how he could kill his brother.
“He pounded his chest, and said, ‘I’m proud of what I did, I put down a sick dog or animal,’” saying that his tone changed, his facial expression was grim, not angry but determined.
It made her feel “gobsmacked.”
She then asked what he did with the body, to which she testified he said, “If you run over a body with a tractor and some kind of implement I can’t remember, enough times, there’s nothing left of it,” in a neutral tone.
She told court she didn’t have the words to describe how devastated she was to think about Patrick being ground up, applied it to herself.
“I was frightened to death.”
When asked what happened after those comments she said, “I don’t remember anything for two years and three months.”
Hayes was diagnosed with colon cancer in 1999, and that is when she started remembering again.
She added that once she left Joseph in 2010, he threatened her in 2011 to not tell the cops so she wrote a letter, which she later gave to police.
During testimony, the Crown asked if Joseph and Patrick had any altercations and Hayes recalled them owning farmland together and Pat being “unwell.” He was on leave from his job at the time.
The defence asked questions in regards to the timeline, what happened and if Hayes could recall as facts, what happened, when, and how.
As to why Hayes waited years to come forward with a testimony, she said she was scared for her life and felt threatened by Joe coming home from his daughter Fran’s wedding in 2011.
She left Thaughberger in 2010 to move to Alberta and take care of her children.
On the way back to Regina from the wedding in Yorkton, Hayes recalls Joe realizing she was never coming back to him.
She testified that he said, “If I ever go to jail because of you, I will kill you, and if I can’t do it, I have people who will. You have no idea how powerful I am, don’t say no to me.”
According to Hayes, Joseph Thaughberger owned a significant amount of property, though he never had it in his name. He demanded she sign over the property he put in her name to his children and made sure it was done sometime in the year that followed.
Hayes was scared for her life, especially after that conversation, she told the courtroom.
“It seemed like a promise, not a threat.”
Because of this, she then documented everything she could remember on Sept. 3rd, 1997 and the days that followed leading to the conversation in the kitchen.
“I felt very threatened, I wrote a letter, that I kept at my house, describing everything that had happened, in the event that I should disappear,” Hayes said.
She wrote a second letter in 2014 and eventually gave it to her lawyer, whom she presumed handed it over to police at a later date.
Hayes said she thinks about the events of that day continuously and once she was arrested felt “relief that I could unburden this horrible secret.”
Hayes was never charged with accessory to murder and became a witness for the crown after her statement to police.
“Most of this has gone over in my head every day for 25 and three-quarter years,” Hayes said.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
DEVELOPING Russia says a Ukrainian missile strike hit its Black Sea Fleet headquarters, a serviceman is missing
Ukraine carried out a missile strike Friday on the headquarters of Russia's Black Sea Fleet, a Russian official said, and images on social media showed large plumes of smoke said to be coming from Sevastopol harbour in the annexed Crimea.
Telling the difference between a developing case of the flu, a cold or COVID-19 is even more difficult than before, as more distinctive symptoms such as the loss of taste or smell have become less common over time, experts say.
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy and First Lady of Ukraine Olena Zelenska arrived in Canada Thursday night, and have a full day of events ahead of them today, in Ottawa and Toronto.
'It's so heartwarming to see them grow': Six rescued harbour seals return to the waters off B.C.'s coast
Six rescued harbour seals, which were cared for by the Vancouver Aquarium's Marine Mammal Rescue Centre, have been released back into the wild.
As Canadians report their frustrations with 'out-of-control' tipping culture, some wonder whether it is time to remove the option to tip at restaurants and is it even possible amid rising food costs?
An Ontario woman is warning others after a fraudster impersonating a Service Canada employee convinced her to empty out $50,000 from her bank account.
A new study from the C.D. Howe Institute compares seniors’ care in Canada to that of other wealthy nations, providing insights into its relative performance and areas for improvement.
Most of the 700-plus offenders deemed as the most dangerous in Canada are housed in medium- and minimum-security prisons, federal statistics show.
There are just two sleeps until the Saskatoon Blades and Regina Pats kick off their regular season Saturday night in Regina.
The owners of a Saskatoon apartment building tried to evict a woman for coming up $150 short on rent, according to a report from the office of residential tenancies.
A new RBC survey suggests many Canadians face increasing financial uncertainty, as dwindling savings begin to hamper future financial security.
Manitoba's three main party leaders squared off over health care, the cost of living and other issues during a one-hour televised leaders debate Thursday night in advance of the Oct. 3 provincial election.
Hundreds of students in Winnipeg were absent Wednesday due to 'misinformation' and pressure in the community amid widespread protests and counterprotests over gender identity in the classroom, school officials say.
The Winnipeg Police Service is investigating the city’s 26th homicide of the year.
The death of Calgarian Tristan Anderson is prompting his family to push for changes to make CTrain and bus stations safer.
A Calgary medical student has developed an app that allows future doctors to work on their diagnostic and communication skills before they set up their practices.
Betty Ann Williams died after her neighbours' three large dogs got loose and attacked while she was gardening outside her home.
Premier Danielle Smith is keeping MLA Jason Stephan in her UCP caucus despite an Alberta NDP demand to remove him for speaking at a '1MillionMarch4Children' protest.
Feedback generated by an engagement panel formed by the Alberta government in the wake of news it is considering forming a provincial pension plan will determine whether the idea will go to a referendum, Premier Danielle Smith said Thursday.
Photo of bedroom where young girl was sexually assaulted released by Alberta police to identify victim
Alberta police are trying to identify a sexual assault victim who is believed to be six to 10 years old.
Two people have been transported to hospital with life-threatening injuries following an overnight shooting call in the Dorset Park area.
Road closures for Ukrainian President Zelenskyy's visit to Ottawa
CTVNewsOttawa.ca looks at things to do in Ottawa, eastern Ontario and western Quebec this weekend.
Final official day of summer will be full of sunshine
A grieving family is outraged that the man accused in a double killing in Chilliwack last week is being released on bail.
'They were good men': Colleague remembers 4 B.C. wildland firefighters killed in head-on collision near Kamloops
A team leader at Tomahawk Ventures, a company contracted by the province to fight forest fires, is remembering four colleagues who died when their pickup truck crashed into a semi truck on the Trans-Canada Highway near Kamloops early Tuesday morning.
It may be happening too slow for some and too fast for others, but technological innovations are taking place in British Columbia's municipalities, with cybersecurity and funding key considerations as they move forward.
Two strip mall merchants in the West Island of Montreal have closed for several days while a festival goes on at their doorstep. The Pointe-Claire Deli and Bramble House shared on social media that while Le Grand PoutineFest is ongoing in the parking lot out front—they are closed.
Until this week, Sukhwinder Dhillon was set on making his first trip back to India in years sometime in the next few months. “My father passed, and my brother passed,” said the 56-year-old Montrealer. “I want to go now.”
A lack of affordable and available housing in the capital region is being blamed for keeping people away who are desperately needed in order to correct the ailing health-care system.
The parents of a Nanaimo teenager who was struck in a crosswalk and later died in hospital have been awarded $327,635 after a B.C. Supreme Court judge recognized the Korean practice of hyodo, in which a child is expected to provide financial and domestic support to their parents.
Two people were airlifted to hospital with minor injuries after their small plane crashed Wednesday morning on northern Vancouver Island. A spokesperson for the Transportation Safety Board of Canada tells CTV News the privately owned de Havilland Beaver aircraft "collided with the terrain" approximately 18 kilometres southwest of Campbell River.
Some are weary of Nova Scotia Power's promises for improvement, as fall hurricane season brings lengthy power outages he feels could be avoided.
RCMP in New Brunswick say the disappearance of a 58-year-old Sunny Corner man is being investigated as a homicide.
Cybersecurity Breach: MOVEit costs N.S. taxpayers more than $3 million; personal info from thousands still at risk
N.S. MOVEit cyber hack price tag $2.85 million for credit monitoring services alone.
The Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry says it is investigating “a matter” related to the Top 50 Classic tournament held earlier this month on Lake Nipissing.
Red-light cameras in Sudbury have been busy in the last year catching drivers at different locations in the city.
Regional police are looking into an alleged stabbing that left one person dead in Uptown Waterloo.
It comes less than a week after the symphony abruptly cancelled its upcoming season and days after leadership announced they needed to secure $2 million by Friday to avoid insolvency.
Premier Doug Ford said he will be reversing his government’s decision to open up the Greenbelt to developers, calling the controversial land removals a “mistake.”