In Regina cold case trial, accused killer's ex-wife says she was asked to help move body
The murder trial for Joseph Thauberger resumed Thursday, with testimony from his then wife Barbara Hayes.
Thauberger stands accused of killing his brother, who was reported missing to police in 1997.
Hayes took the stand for the Crown, telling the court the events she remembered from Sept. 3 1997.
Hayes said she ran a daycare in the basement of 2721 Francis St., where she and the accused lived at the time.
On the day of the alleged incident, she said she was taking care of five children.
“I did notice James and Pat and Joe in the driveway, the windows were very large and high, they were talking. James left, Pat and Joe came in the house, went upstairs,” she told the courtroom. She believed that James was dropping Patrick off so he could take him back to the bus stop.
She remembered carrying on with the children, and at about lunchtime, she went upstairs to get something from the cupboard, and saw Patrick reclining on the couch with his arm on the back.
“We waved and said hi to each other,” she recalled.
She then testified that she went back downstairs, to take care of the children, and 10 minutes later heard a “tremendous crash, like an elephant was going to come through the ceiling.”
Hayes told court the children all looked up and asked what the noise was. She said she heard Patrick saying, ‘No, no, no.’
“I heard it very plainly, it seemed loud to me,” she said.
She said she waited 30 seconds then went up to the basement door, which was locke, something she recalled never occurred in her house before.
Hayes testified to banging on the door and asking Joseph Thauberger, “What have you done?” To which she said he responded, “Go back downstairs.”
She said she remembers waiting no more than a couple minutes before returning downstairs to care for the children.
Hayes testified that she remained in the basement for the rest of the day. She didn’t recall when the children left but remembers around the time it got dark, 8:30 p.m. she estimates, Joseph called for her.
She described him as looking like he was ready to go to the farm, with a plaid jacket and rubber boots.
"He asked me if I could help him move him,” she told the Crown. The lawyer asked, ‘Who, Pat?”
“That’s who he meant,” she said.
“Maybe I said no, maybe it was just my inside voice that said no, I just stood at the bottom of the stairs,” she told the courtroom.
She testified saying there was a blue carpet that was rolled up at the top of the stairs, and believed Patrick’s body was wrapped in the rolled up carpet.
Hayes added that Joseph had a hard time moving the carpet and testified she never saw the carpet again.
She said she went upstairs to make sure Joseph did not hit the railing, then went back downstairs.
Though the timeline she recalled was fuzzy as she stated, the occurrence of events she is sure of.
During her testimony, she said she finally went upstairs later in the night, tired and wanting sleep. She saw the cupboard door that had a gash in it that wasn’t there before and saw shoe skid marks on the floor of the kitchen.
She cannot recall when Joseph came back and what day they spoke again.
The home of Joseph Thauberger, 2721 Francis St. (Gareth Dillistone)
Later in cross-examination, Hayes said she thought maybe the crash had happened in the kitchen, since she saw the gash in the cupboard door and saw the shoe marks in the kitchen.
However, now looking at it, she is not certain it happened in the kitchen, and cannot confirm where the crash happened.
Hayes testified to a conversation in the days following, probably in the afternoon, in the kitchen where she and Joseph spoke about the incident.
She said she asked him why and how he could kill his brother.
“He pounded his chest, and said, ‘I’m proud of what I did, I put down a sick dog or animal,’” saying that his tone changed, his facial expression was grim, not angry but determined.
It made her feel “gobsmacked.”
She then asked what he did with the body, to which she testified he said, “If you run over a body with a tractor and some kind of implement I can’t remember, enough times, there’s nothing left of it,” in a neutral tone.
She told court she didn’t have the words to describe how devastated she was to think about Patrick being ground up, applied it to herself.
“I was frightened to death.”
When asked what happened after those comments she said, “I don’t remember anything for two years and three months.”
Hayes was diagnosed with colon cancer in 1999, and that is when she started remembering again.
She added that once she left Joseph in 2010, he threatened her in 2011 to not tell the cops so she wrote a letter, which she later gave to police.
During testimony, the Crown asked if Joseph and Patrick had any altercations and Hayes recalled them owning farmland together and Pat being “unwell.” He was on leave from his job at the time.
The defence asked questions in regards to the timeline, what happened and if Hayes could recall as facts, what happened, when, and how.
As to why Hayes waited years to come forward with a testimony, she said she was scared for her life and felt threatened by Joe coming home from his daughter Fran’s wedding in 2011.
She left Thaughberger in 2010 to move to Alberta and take care of her children.
On the way back to Regina from the wedding in Yorkton, Hayes recalls Joe realizing she was never coming back to him.
She testified that he said, “If I ever go to jail because of you, I will kill you, and if I can’t do it, I have people who will. You have no idea how powerful I am, don’t say no to me.”
According to Hayes, Joseph Thaughberger owned a significant amount of property, though he never had it in his name. He demanded she sign over the property he put in her name to his children and made sure it was done sometime in the year that followed.
Hayes was scared for her life, especially after that conversation, she told the courtroom.
“It seemed like a promise, not a threat.”
Because of this, she then documented everything she could remember on Sept. 3rd, 1997 and the days that followed leading to the conversation in the kitchen.
“I felt very threatened, I wrote a letter, that I kept at my house, describing everything that had happened, in the event that I should disappear,” Hayes said.
She wrote a second letter in 2014 and eventually gave it to her lawyer, whom she presumed handed it over to police at a later date.
Hayes said she thinks about the events of that day continuously and once she was arrested felt “relief that I could unburden this horrible secret.”
Hayes was never charged with accessory to murder and became a witness for the crown after her statement to police.
“Most of this has gone over in my head every day for 25 and three-quarter years,” Hayes said.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
From ultra-low interest rates that led to a huge spike in real estate demand to the speed with which interest rates shot up to levels not seen in a generation, it's been hard to keep up with the shifting landscape for mortgage holders.
McDonald's and Wendy's have defeated a lawsuit accusing them of deceiving hungry diners by exaggerating the size of their burgers.
Researchers have come up with categories for people who are addicted to the internet and for those who are at risk.
An Environment Canada advisory that singled out Diwali fireworks as a reason to prepare for poor air quality last October was issued despite multiple warnings from some staff about it being discriminatory.
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has yet to issue mandate letters for his cabinet ministers, two months after announcing an overhaul to his front bench.
We know the second planet from the Sun to be an inhospitable place, cloaked in thick, yellow clouds of sulfuric acid – but according to a new study, a hypothetical trip to Venus might not be full of thunder and lightning.
Images captured by satellite show that the damage left in the wake of some of Canada's worst wildfires.
The UN Security Council voted Monday to send a multinational force to Haiti led by Kenya to help combat violent gangs in the troubled Caribbean country.
Former major league pitcher Trevor Bauer and a woman who accused him of beating and sexually assaulting her in 2021 have settled their legal dispute, Bauer's attorneys said Monday.
Saskatoon Transit is renewing calls for its own dedicated team of community support officers (CSOs) to help respond to incidents on buses and transit terminals.
A Saskatchewan First Nation has declared a state of emergency after a spate of seven overdoses in a single day.
George Reed, one of the most prolific running backs in Canadian Football League (CFL) history and a legend of the Saskatchewan Roughriders, has passed away. He was 83.
WINNIPEG -- Manitoba Progressive Conservative Leader Heather Stefanson reiterated promises to cut taxes, spend new money on health care and tackle crime in her final announcement before Tuesday's election.
A Winnipeg family is in mourning after a mother of three was killed by a alleged drunk driver last week.
RCMP in Selkirk are looking for the public's help in finding a missing 30-year-old woman.
Police believe two shootings in southwest and southeast Calgary over the weekend are connected and targeted the same person.
Grizzly bear experts say fatal attacks are extremely rare, but it's always a risk when people venture into the wilderness.
Calgary city council is discussing a proposed transit safety strategy on Monday, in an effort to address concerns about the number of incidents on public transit.
A 39-year-old man is dead after he was found injured outside a downtown Edmonton shelter Sunday afternoon.
An Edmonton man is dead after he was hit by a vehicle in the Leduc area Monday morning.
Grizzly bear experts say fatal attacks are extremely rare, but it's always a risk when people venture into the wilderness.
Bonnie Crombie has raised nearly one million dollars in her bid for leadership of the Ontario Liberals, tens of thousands of which appear to have come from one developer based in the Toronto area.
A Toronto police officer with 15 years of service has been arrested and charged in connection with an assault investigation.
A man in his 50s from Oakville, Ont. has been arrested and charged after allegedly selling advertisements and soliciting funds using a fake magazine for more than a decade.
Ottawa police say a woman in her 40s is dead after a driver struck her and another person in Sandy Hill.
Ontario Provincial Police say a driver suffered a life-threatening injury in an overnight crash on Highway 417 that involved horses that had wandered onto the highway.
Ottawa police say there are no reports of any significant issues following Sunday's Panda Game between the University of Ottawa and Carleton University.
A 19-year-old driver with a learner's licence was clocked going 199 km/h while racing through North Vancouver, B.C., over the weekend, according to Mounties.
A massive fire in Vancouver's Kerrisdale neighbourhood that broke out Sunday night has completely destroyed four businesses, according to officials.
A female grizzly bear and her two older cubs have been trapped and relocated after frequenting areas around Nelson in southeastern British Columbia.
A 12-year-old girl drowned Sunday at the Bedard Quarry in Kahnawake, Que., on Montreal's South Shore. Kahnawake Peacekeepers say they were called to the scene just before 5:30 p.m. When they arrived, two non-local youth told them their 12-year-old friend had jumped into the water from a cliff and had not resurfaced.
A 79-year-old woman was killed on Saturday in a seniors' residence in Terrebonne, in the Lanaudière region north of Montreal. An 81-year-old man is considered a suspect in the case, but he is still unconscious in hospital.
Sûreté du Québec (SQ) divers found the lifeless body of a five-year-old child who had fallen into the Saint-Maurice River in the Mauricie region at noon on Monday.
A swimmer drowned in Thetis Lake Friday afternoon, according to West Shore RCMP.
The leader of the Conservative Party of BC is defending a social media post about parental rights denounced as insensitive, hurtful and political on the National Day for Truth and Reconciliation.
A group of orcas that inhabit Canadian waters are known to harass and kill porpoises without eating them. A new study tries to explain why.
Police say they've made arrests and issued summary offence tickets after an "unsanctioned student gathering" in Halifax.
A sell-out crowd of nearly 5,000 fans filled Sydney's Centre 200 on Sunday to witness the first NHL Exhibition game on the island in a long-time.
Amid a cost-of-living crisis driving up food bank visits and economic anxiety, the minimum wage increased in six provinces today – but both advocates and critics fear it may not be enough to tackle the overarching problem.
Tragedy has struck another northern Ontario family, as a 14-year-old boy from Wahnapitae First Nation was killed in an ATV rollover marking the 10th death in the region involving an off-road vehicle since July.
A 35-year-old northern Ontario driver is charged with impaired driving after allegedly evading Royal Canadian Mounted Police in Manitoba, throwing beer cans out the window and assaulting his passenger before crashing vehicle into a ditch.
A violent attack on man lying on the ground in a downtown Sudbury underpass tunnel was captured on surveillance video and police are looking for the third suspect who fled.
Waterloo regional police have arrested four teenagers after they say a Pride flag was taken from a Kitchener high school, trampled on, and burned.
OPP have arrested a 16-year-old after they say around 150 youths were involved in numerous fights at the fairgrounds in Caledonia.
Four people are officially in the running to become Cambridge's next Ward 1 councillor.