Closing arguments in former Sask. hockey coach's sexual assault trial heard
-- The following story contains details that some readers may find disturbing.
Lawyers delivered their final arguments before a judge on Friday, capping off the week-long sex assault trial for former Saskatchewan junior hockey coach Bernie Lynch.
In the eyes of the defense, it is a he said, he said case.
“No one will ever really know what happened that day except for Bernard Lynch and [the complainant],” defense lawyer Andrew Hitchcock said in his closing remarks, reminding the judge that his client is still presumed innocent.
“The default is to come to the conclusion that it’s better to let ten guilty people go than put one innocent person in prison.”
Lynch, 69, is on trial for one count of sexual assault and one count of assault against a 17-year-old boy. The alleged incidents took place in August 1988 when the complainant claimed he was helping Lynch instruct a hockey school put on by the Regina Pats.
The complainant, who testified earlier this week, described in detail how Lynch sexually assaulted him in the shower. Prior to the assault, the complainant told the court that he was staying at Lynch’s apartment for one night as part of the accommodations provided by the Pats. He testified the coach bought beer for them, suggested they rent an adult film and offered for the teen to bunk in his bed because that’s what hockey players do on the road.
The accused denies the allegations and claims he was out of province at a coach's conference and separate hockey tournament at the time the alleged incidents took place.
On Thursday, Lynch testified he invited the complainant, a junior hockey player at the time, to help coach the hockey school in Regina. Lynch said he met the teen at a gas station two days before the camp was set to begin, helped him check into his hotel and showed him to the hockey rink that same night. Lynch claims that was the extent of their interactions before he got onto a plane to Calgary the next morning.
“There’s no evidence that this is wrong, that this isn’t true other than the complainant,” Hitchcock told the judge.
“[Lynch’s] version is not implausible.”
While under oath, Lynch changed his answers when asked several times if it was possible he took the teen to his apartment. He originally told the defense it was possible, before backtracking and telling the Crown he was certain he did not go to his apartment with the teen.
Hitchcock chalked up the contradicting answers to nerves.
“This is a highly emotional situation for Mr. Lynch. He’s accused of molesting a teenager. Even though he’s presumed innocent, there’s no publication ban to protect his identity. His name is out there. His face is out there and has been for a long time. This kind of stress wears on a person,” Hitchcock said.
“In 35 years his name has been completely tarnished. Even if he’s vindicated by an acquittal in this trial, to be vindicated in the eyes of the public is likely not possible for him.”
However, Crown prosecutor Chris White called it “suspect” that Lynch couldn’t give a direct answer to the question.
“What else is he unsure of? What else is he not telling us? What else is he leaving out?” White questioned.
White agreed with the defense that the evidence does not leave “much wiggle room” when it comes to determining what happened.
“There’s no gray here. It happened or it didn’t. There’s nothing in between,” White said in court.
However, White argued some of Lynch’s testimony actually corroborated the alleged victim’s evidence.
Both the complainant and the accused agreed there is a “culture of silence” within the hockey community, especially back in the 1980s.
“What happens on the road, stays on the road”, White said, suggesting that way of thinking served as a mitigating risk factor for Lynch to carry out the alleged offence.
White argued the complainant’s evidence is reliable and credible, and should be believed based on the amount of detail given in his testimony.
On the other hand, White argued Lynch’s testimony was inconsistent and “a study in contrast.” White said, at times, the accused was combative and evasive, while at other moments he was cordial and candid.
“Mr. Lynch’s evidence was less about informing you and more about persuading you,” White told the judge.
“You should not believe him when he said he wasn’t there.”
White ended his arguments by telling the judge it would be unsafe not to convict Lynch.
The judge is expected to deliver his decision on Dec. 1.
The Shopping Trends team is independent of the journalists at CTV News. We may earn a commission when you use our links to shop. Read about us.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Vladimir Putin on Friday moved to prolong his repressive and unyielding grip on Russia for at least another six years, announcing his candidacy in the presidential election next March that he is all but certain to win, according to state media reports.
Here's a list of items Health Canada and the Canadian Food Inspection Agency recalled this week, including mushrooms, more caffeinated energy drinks, and electric cooktops.
The director of public prosecutions in the Caribbean nation of Dominica has confirmed that two men have been charged in the death of Quebecer Daniel Langlois and his partner.
Judge rules in favour of NBA star, nullifies purchase of $8M Burlington mansion once occupied by 'crypto king'
A judge has ruled in favour of NBA star Shai Gilgeous-Alexander in his lawsuit against a company that sold him a Burlington mansion previously occupied by self-proclaimed ‘crypto king’ Aiden Pleterski.
Advocates sound the alarm on increased deportations in Canada, urge feds to fulfil regularization promise
Advocates are sounding the alarm on the rise in deportations in Canada and are calling on the federal government to follow through on its 2021 promise to expand a regularization program for undocumented people living in the country.
A French juvenile court is handing down a verdict Friday for six teenagers accused of involvement in the killing of teacher Samuel Paty, who was beheaded by an Islamic extremist after he showed caricatures of the Prophet Muhammad to his class for a debate on freedom of expression.
One of the biggest and brightest stars in the night sky will momentarily vanish as an asteroid passes in front of it to produce a one-of-a-kind eclipse.
Prince Harry lost a preliminary round Friday in his libel case against the publisher of the Daily Mail tabloid over an article that said he tried to hide his efforts to retain publicly funded protection in the U.K. after giving up his status as a working member of the royal family.
The Conservatives launch an overnight marathon voting session, two men are charged in the death of a Quebecer and his partner in Dominica and five people are dead in a salmonella outbreak involving cantaloupes. Here's what you need to know to start your day.
A former Saskatchewan Mountie charged with first-degree murder says his alleged victim sometimes blackmailed and forced to him have sex.
The majority of Saskatoon special care homes may be "chemically" managing residents with anti-psychotic drugs, an independent audit found.
The Saskatoon Blades are back from a long U.S. road trip, and they’re right back in action this weekend with three games in three nights.
A basketball referee is facing sexual assault charges after Winnipeg police say two victims have come forward.
A number of southern Manitoba cities, towns and communities broke heat records on Wednesday, with above-seasonal temperatures expected to continue for the next few days.
Four people have been arrested in connection with the stabbing death of a 36-year-old man one week ago.
Some quick thinking from witnesses of a crash in northeast Calgary on Wednesday helped rescue a two-year-old girl who was trapped under a vehicle.
Alberta's health minister is facing pushback after taking a meeting focused on naturopathic medicine's role in the province's primary care.
We are done with the bulk of the snowfall but still, a little more is possible.
Alberta politicians wrapped up the fall sitting of the legislature in the early hours Thursday, with Premier Danielle Smith's government cutting off debate to pass a bill mandating a referendum be held before the province could quit the Canada Pension Plan.
Police shot and killed a woman in southeast Edmonton on Wednesday.
Old Strathcona business association expands vandalism grant program, asks governments for more support
A southside business association is expanding a program to help shops in its neighbourhood deal with damage from vandalism.
A man is dead after being shot by police officers north of Toronto during a call for a domestic disturbance on Wednesday night.
Cyber Monday and Black Friday may have come and gone, but sales on TVs continue through December right up until the holidays.
A man is in hospital with non-life-threatening injuries following an overnight shooting at a Scarborough tow yard.
NEW THIS MORNING
NEW THIS MORNING What's happening in Ottawa this weekend: Dec. 8-10
CTVNewsOttawa.ca looks at things to do in Ottawa, eastern Ontario and western Quebec this weekend.
Environment Canada's forecast calls for above-seasonal temperatures of plus 2 C on Saturday and 6 C on Sunday in Ottawa, before cold temperatures return next week.
A person is in critical condition after a two-vehicle crash in Ottawa on Thursday afternoon.
Three times she went to Langley Memorial Hospital's emergency room for help. Three times, she said, she was sent home.
A British Columbia Supreme Court jury has retired to deliberate in the first-degree murder trial of Ibrahim Ali, more than eight months after he pleaded not guilty to killing a 13-year-old girl in a Metro Vancouver park in 2017.
Was the order to dismantle a Downtown Eastside homeless encampment legal? Here's what the court decided.
An order by Vancouver's fire chief to clear an encampment on the Downtown Eastside was "unlawful and invalid," according to a lawyer who represented residents in a court challenge of the order.
Public sector workers in schools, health care institutions, CEGEPs and social services are starting a seven-day strike.
The majority of confirmed Canadian cases in the ongoing cantaloupe salmonella outbreak are in Quebec, according to health officials.
Those planning trips to or from the Island of Montreal on the weekend should note that there are several route closures to be expected. The Louis-Hippolyte-La Fontaine tunnel, the Saint-Pierre interchange and on the Highway 15 in the Atwater Avenue sector will all feature closures and should be avoided, as well as others listed below.
The skeletal remains of a 39-year-old hiker who went missing in the southern Vancouver Island backcountry one year ago have been found.
The busy Christmas travel season is almost upon us and this year the Victoria International Airport says it’s been working hard to prevent a repeat of the days-long travel chaos that happened last year.
A driver is dead after a single-vehicle crash in Nanaimo Thursday.
The Maritime provinces are leading the country in lengthy healthcare wait times, showing a stark contrast to the national average.
Social Development Minister Jill Green says a temporary solution for the homeless crisis in St. Stephen could come as soon as Friday morning.
The Saint John Police Force says four people have been arrested for weapons offences, after a report of “armed peoples” entering a home in the city.
A recent report of more than 30 experts from several universities says some relief is coming at the grocery checkout in 2024.
Despite some critical comments from Ontario’s auditor general, the CEO of Science North wants to reassure northerners that the science centre is thriving.
GRAPHIC WARNING: A North Bay, Ont., mother is shocked after being told no charges will be laid against a school bus driver accused of sexually assaulting her now four-year-old daughter on her first day of school.
A Brantford, Ont. woman who faked being pregnant to defraud doulas and obtain care under false pretences has pleaded guilty to multiple charges, including fraud, mischief and committing indecent acts.
Sofyan Taya, a former guest scholar at the University of Waterloo in Ontario, was reportedly killed in an Israeli airstrike near Gaza City. His friend and former colleague called him a brilliant and gentle soul.
The IIHF World Junior Hockey Championship is just around the corner - an exciting time for hockey fans across Canada.