Sask. doctor acquitted of sexual assault charges can still be sued in civil claim, judge rules
Some readers may find details in this story disturbing.
A Regina doctor accused of sexually assaulting patients can still be sued in civil proceedings even though he’s been acquitted of the charges in criminal court, a Saskatoon judge has ruled.
Gastroenterologist Sylvester Ukabam went to trial in 2022 over seven counts of sexual assault stemming from incidents with five separate patients. The women said he vaginally penetrated them or performed breast exams without consent and with no explanation of the medical reasons for the procedures.
None of the accusers can be named due to a publication ban.
At trial, a medical expert testified there would be no reason for a gastroenterologist to examine a woman’s breasts or vagina in the course of their duties.
Ukabam testified he had no memory of the encounters and relied only on his notes from the examinations. He was acquitted by Court of King’s Bench Justice Brian Scherman, who said the women were mistaken about what they felt, because they were under sedation or influenced by the initial complaints in the media. This prompted a complaint against him by one of the accusers.
The Crown lost a subsequent appeal to overturn the doctor’s acquittal, but in February, one patient opted to file a civil claim.
Ukabam asked a King’s Bench judge to strike down the patient’s civil lawsuit since the “essential fact underlying” her claim was already decided in criminal court.
But in a decision earlier this month, Judge Neil Robertson said the lawsuit can proceed.
“The acquittal on the criminal charge is not a bar to the civil claim,” Robertson wrote in his Aug.7 decision.
“The different standard of proof and the civil wrongs alleged mean the claim could succeed, despite the criminal acquittal.”
In criminal trials, the Crown has to prove “beyond a reasonable doubt” that the accused committed an offense — a standard that is near absolute certainty.
In civil cases, a plaintiff only has to prove their case on a balance of probabilities — essentially, that it’s the most likely scenario.
At Ukabam’s 2022 trial, judge Scherman was left with a reasonable doubt that the complainants’ statements — all seven of them — may not be completely reliable.
“The overarching issue in respect of the complainant’s evidence is the reliability of their respective evidence,” he said.
“There is, at minimum, a reasonable possibility that each of the complainants misinterpreted and/or do not reliably remember what occurred.”
In a June 2022 complaint against Scherman to the Canadian Judicial Council, one of the accusers said the judge’s decision reflected an underlying attitude of ignorance, misogyny and gender bias that was deeply unsettling.
In the February Saskatchewan appeal court decision upholding the doctor’s acquittal, Justice Lian Schwann concluded that judge Scherman made some errors by omitting some of the Crown’s evidence, but she was not convinced it would have made a difference.
Ukabam gave up his medical licence in 2018 and opted not to try to return to the profession after the trial.
-With files from Canadian Press and Stefanie Davis
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Air Canada travellers share worries and frustrations ahead of possible pilot strike
Here's what customers had to say about their travel plans ahead of a potential Air Canada pilot strike.
Trudeau says Ukraine can strike deep into Russia with NATO arms, Putin hints at war
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau says Ukraine should be allowed to strike deep inside Russia, regardless of Moscow threatening that this would draw Canada and its allies into direct war.
Driver charged with killing NHL's Johnny Gaudreau and his brother had .087 blood-alcohol level
The driver charged with killing NHL hockey player Johnny Gaudreau and his brother Matthew as they bicycled on a rural road had a blood-alcohol level of .087, above the .08 legal limit in New Jersey, a prosecutor said Friday.
23-year-old Muskoka, Ont., resident highlights the need for rural health care after stroke
The experience of 23-year-old Muskoka, Ont., resident Robyn Penniall, who recently had a stroke, comes as concerns are being raised about the future of health care in her community.
24-packs of Kirkland Signature Greek yogurt recalled over mould
Kirkland Signature Greek yogurt 24-packs are being recalled in Canada due to mould.
2 suspects charged after Lamborghini stolen in armed home invasion in Richmond Hill: police
York Regional Police say they have arrested two suspects and are looking for at least one more following an armed home invasion in Richmond Hill that saw thieves escape in the victim’s Lamborghini.
Former NHL enforcer Stephen Peat dies after being hit by car in B.C.
Stephen Peat, the former Washington Capitals enforcer who fought concussion issues and was homeless at times after leaving hockey, has died from injuries sustained late last month when he was struck by a car while crossing a street. He was 44.
Stuck-in-space astronauts make first public comments since Boeing capsule left without them
Stuck-in-space astronauts Butch Wilmore and Suni Williams said Friday they appreciated all the prayers and well wishes from strangers back home.
Ontario's top court dismisses application for bail from Jacob Hoggard
Jacob Hoggard will remain behind bars while he tries to appeal his sexual assault conviction at Canada's top court, a justice with Ontario's Appeal Court ruled Friday, calling the musician's attempt unlikely to succeed.