Sexual assault trial of former Regina doctor considers potential expert witness
WARNING: This story includes details of sexual assault allegations.
The sexual assault trial of a former Regina doctor continued on Monday with the court hearing from a potential expert witness.
The Crown called Dr. Barry Lumb, a gastroenterologist and medical professor from Ontario, to take the stand virtually for a voir dire, to see if he could be considered an expert witness on typical practices and procedures of the profession.
Sylvester Ukabam pleaded not guilty to seven counts of sexual assault levelled against him by five women. Ukabam was a gastroenterology specialist. He is accused of inappropriate actions during physical medical examinations of several women at his Regina practice between 2010 and 2018.
The five women testified last week. Friday’s complainant said she went to see Ukabam for stomach pain, but during an exam he touched and penetrated her vagina.
Crown prosecutor Alexandra Findlay had Dr. Lumb go over the process of becoming a fully accredited gastroenterologist. He spoke about his 38 years of experience in the field and the thousands of patients’ exams and scope procedures he has completed throughout his career.
Lumb was asked about sedation and how common it is in gastroenterology. He said it is common and needed to keep patients comfortable. He said there are two types of sedation - one keeps the patient awake during the procedure and was referred to the doctor as conscious sedation. The other, referred to as deep sedation, leaves a patient unconscious. Lumb said he has been using sedation throughout his career.
When asked by the Crown if he commonly is asked to perform breast examinations, Lumb said no.
“I have had very little indication to perform a breast examination,” he said. “It would be uncommon for a gastroenterologist to carry out routine breast examinations.”
Lumb said to prepare for the trial, he had access to police interviews, complainants’ medical records and reports to the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Saskatchewan (CPSS).
He said he was not familiar with Ukabam before this trial and has no past experience with any of the alleged victims, which he said allows him to remain impartial in the trial.
He prepared his own reports from the evidence he had access to. He completed five reports - one for each complainant.
During cross examination on Monday morning, defence lawyer Aaron Fox questioned Lumb’s ability to remain impartial in the trial. Fox cited changes that had been made to Lumb’s reports on the five alleged victims following interactions with the Crown’s office.
In emails between Lumb and the Crown that were presented in the courtroom, the Crown suggested Lumb should remove certain parts of his drafted reports about complaints to the CPSS and to clarify his opinion in a stronger way.
The emails also suggested that Lumb should remove any reference to Ukabam committing sexual assaults, saying that was “for the jury to decide.”
Fox asked Lumb if his reports had been influenced by emotion.
Lumb said the response that he initially had “perhaps been overly emotional,” but that did not find its way into the final reports.
Fox highlighted an email from Lumb on March 10, 2021 that said “I’m struggling for words to describe my outrage,” at what he had read in the complaints made by the alleged victims.
Crown counsel was given an opportunity to re-examine the witness.
She asked Lumb why the reports from the alleged victims had made him emotional. He said as a practicing gastroenterologist and physician that spends time with trainees, what he had read went far beyond what he would ever expect.
He said his emotional response did not impact his medical opinion on what he has read, and he reaffirmed his ability to remain impartial.
During submissions at the end of the day, Fox said Lumb did not clearly state in his reports that he was clear on what his role in this process was.
Fox read aloud the court rules which state that expert witnesses have a duty to be impartial, independent and unbiased.
“I’m not sure that this witness was aware of that duty,” Fox said. “The concern that you have, is: does this witness understand what his role is?’’
Ultimately, Fox said the defence’s position is that based on the various comments the witness made, the proper ruling would be that he is not an admissible expert witness who can remain impartial.
He said if Lumb is found admissible as a witness, the weight of his statements should be considered.
During her submission, the Crown confirmed that all drafts of Lumb’s reports and any correspondents regarding the reports have been provided to the defence and the court.
She said there was nothing in the correspondence with the Crown that would lead Lumb to form any opinion, other than his own medical opinion from what he read from the evidence.
Findlay highlighted that Lumb had repeated several times, he would enter the trial with an open mind.
“There is no question that Dr. Lumb is properly educated, properly experienced and properly knowledgeable,” Lane said.
Lane said it is possible for Lumb to form his expert opinion and then from that form a personal opinion, while still remaining unbiased.
The judge said he will need the entire day on Tuesday to make a decision on if Dr. Lumb is a qualified expert witness.
Court will resume at 10:00 a.m. on Wednesday.
Regina Top Stories
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
The police official blamed for not sending officers in more quickly to stop the Uvalde, Texas, school shooting is the chief of the school system's small police force, a unit dedicated ordinarily to building relationships with students and responding to the occasional fight.
Russia asserted Saturday that its troops and separatist fighters had captured a key railway junction in eastern Ukraine, the second small city to fall to Moscow's forces this week as they fought to seize all of the country's contested Donbas region.
The World Economic Forum’s annual meeting in Davos was met with justifiable criticisms and unfounded conspiracy theories.
Federal Conservative leadership candidate Patrick Brown says calling social conservatives 'dinosaurs' in a book he wrote about his time in Ontario politics was 'the wrong terminology.'
Speakers at the National Rifle Association annual meeting assailed a Chicago gun ban that doesn't exist, ignored security upgrades at the Texas school where children were slaughtered and roundly distorted national gun and crime statistics as they pushed back against any tightening of gun laws.
An 11-year-old survivor of the Robb Elementary School massacre in Uvalde, Texas, feared the gunman would come back for her so she smeared herself in her friend's blood and played dead.
The Supreme Court of Canada’s ruling allowing the Quebec City mosque shooter to be eligible for parole after 25 years is raising concern for more than a dozen similar cases.
A seven-person civil jury in Virginia will resume deliberations Tuesday in Johnny Depp's libel trial against Amber Heard. What the jury considers will be very different from the public debate that has engulfed the high-profile proceedings.
Barrett Ross says his dog Indy suffered a punctured bowel, lost a tooth and had his stomach injured when he was attacked by three other dogs.
The Saskatoon Tribal Council's (STC) temporary downtown shelter has been granted an extension to operate at its present location until April 2023 — but Tribal Chief Mark Arcand hopes to relocate well before then.
A pedestrian injured by a vehicle in Prince Albert has died.
Pembina Trails School Division is confirming to CTV News that a group of students found a body during community cleanup at Ècole South Pointe School.
Winnipeg police are telling people to find an alternate route this afternoon as they are investigating a fatal crash near the St. Boniface Industrial Park.
'It's one way to be creative': Winnipeg student wants to be a bartender when older; school doesn't like comment in yearbook
Bartender. That is what one Grade 4 student said for the yearbook when asked what he wanted to be when he grows up, an answer the school is asking him to change.
A southern Alberta man who killed three people, including a two-year-old girl, could have the ability to request a release from jail earlier than his original sentence intended, thanks to a landmark Supreme Court decision Friday.
Calgary Flames fans are still coming to terms with a playoff series loss to the Edmonton Oilers Thursday night in a game that saw both controversy and heartbreak following a Connor McDavid overtime goal.
Western Canada's premiers want to reform their health-care systems by expanding services but they say Ottawa first needs to pick up the phone.
A hotly-controversial decision on whether or not to freeze base funding for police in Edmonton was delayed Friday as fallout from a dispute between the mayor and the provincial justice minister continued to rattle political circles.
A 19-year-old man is in police custody after a shooting near Rogers Place after an Edmonton Oilers viewing party ended Thursday evening.
A shelter many expected to remain open until the end of June in Wetaskiwin, Alta., will close a month early.
WATCH | New video appears to show man carrying air rifle on Toronto streets before being killed by police
A man shot dead by police officers near a Toronto elementary school on Thursday afternoon appears to have been captured on home security footage carrying an air rifle moments before the incident.
A 21-year-old Toronto man is facing a slew of charges following a suspected hate-motivated incident at a Jewish school in North York.
Toronto Pearson International is warning travellers and Mississauga residents they may notice unusual activity at the airport this weekend.
Hydro Ottawa is not committing to a new deadline to restore power to thousands of customers, one week after a devastating storm with wind gusts of 190 km/h hit Ottawa.
A Hydro One spokesperson says some people living in remote parts of rural eastern Ontario could be waiting weeks to have power restored after last Saturday’s devastating and deadly storm.
It's the first in-person Ottawa Race Weekend in Ottawa since 2019, after the 2020 and 2021 events were shifted online due to the COVID-19 pandemic.
A B.C. mom with a rare, debilitating illness has spent years trying to get the help she needs. Now she's considering medical assistance in dying.
The number of COVID-19 patients in B.C. hospitals hit its lowest point in more than a month this week, and the decline was driven largely by regions outside the Lower Mainland.
Researchers working in partnership with UBC believe an eco-friendly material could help solve the world’s plastic pollution problem.
Is it unconstitutional to make someone pay to get a legal document translated into French? One of Montreal's top lawyers thinks so, and pointed out two other things from Bill 96 that he thinks the courts would most easily find fault with.
A man in his 80s is fighting for his life after being pulled out of the St. Lawrence River by a fellow resident who saw his vehicle had become submerged.
A large ship carrying chemical products ran aground during its passage through the St. Lawrence Seaway early Friday morning, backing up maritime traffic as tugboats tried to dislodge it.
B.C. speedboat driver arrested with 650kg of meth 'feared for his family's safety,' he told U.S. investigators
New details are emerging after a 51-year-old Alberta man was arrested aboard a speedboat that U.S. authorities say was carrying 650 kilograms of methamphetamine between Washington state and British Columbia.
The emergency department at Port McNeill Hospital unexpectedly shut down on Friday evening due to a staffing shortage.
At least one building was destroyed Friday afternoon as firefighters rushed to a large fire at the vacant Pioneer Square Mall in Mill Bay, B.C.
A Cape Breton father is warning the public of the dangers in the area he lives after his teenager son fell nearly 40 feet over a cliff in Glace Bay.
A lawyer for families of victims killed in the Nova Scotia mass shooting says an 18-hour delay in finding five bodies of those murdered is a sign of "deficient" policing.
The lawyer who represented a man who murdered three RCMP officers nearly eight years ago in Moncton, N.B., said a decision made by the Supreme Court of Canada Friday may potentially change his sentence.
Thursday evening, the Greater Sudbury Chamber of Commerce hosted the 25th annual Bell Business Excellence Awards.
On Friday, there was a walk in Sudbury to remember the remains of 215 residential schoolchildren found in Kamloops, B.C., a year ago May 27.
Staff at the new Sault Metis Centre are getting set for the grand opening Saturday.
A man, who was a referee at high school volleyball games in Guelph for more than 30 years, is facing sex assault-related charges.
The Region of Waterloo says there's a high safety risk at a Kitchener encampment and they are working with residents to prepare them for their eventual move.
Two low-cost airlines are butting heads over an agreement at the Region of Waterloo International Airport. Swoop wants to offer flights but the airport already has an exclusivity deal with rival Flair Airlines