Regina man who killed someone in dispute over $20 could see less prison time
A man who shot and killed someone following a dispute over $20 may be spending less time behind bars.
Following a 2020 jury trial, Chad Barre was convicted of first-degree murder in the death of Justin Langan — a crime that comes with an automatic life sentence with no chance of parole for 25 years.
In a ruling issued last week, the Court of Appeal for Saskatchewan downgraded the conviction to second-degree murder due to concerns about the instructions the jury received.
Langan was fatally shot in his Regina home on Feb. 18, 2018 after Barre and another man arrived brandishing a shotgun and demanding $20 allegedly owed for a methamphetamine purchase.
During Barre's trial, Langan's wife said she tried to stop the men from taking the couple's television in lieu of the debt.
After a "tug of war" over the TV, she said she ended up on the floor and Langan came towards her to help when he was shot.
Barre and the other man left the home with the television in tow and drove away in a truck.
The Court of Appeal's decision largely hinged on whether the jury had enough information to decide if Langan was unlawfully confined during the encounter, an act that would elevate the conviction to first-degree murder.
According to the decision, the Crown argued confinement does not necessarily mean "absolute physical control" and can instead take the form of fear and intimidation.
The Court of Appeal felt the testimony of Langan's wife was not enough to establish that the alleged confinement occurred and that — if it did — it was sufficiently linked to Langan's killing to warrant a first-degree murder conviction.
"The trial judge acknowledged the issues on the evidence and the applicable law but unfortunately failed to adequately equip the jury to address this central issue," the decision said.
While Barre's downgraded conviction of second-degree murder still comes with a life sentence, he could be eligible for parole in as few as ten years based on the outcome of sentencing submissions the Crown and defence are expected to make to the Court of Appeal.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Smith tells Trudeau Alberta will opt out of federal dental plan
Alberta is opting out of the federal dental plan, the premier told the Canadian government late Tuesday afternoon.
One of Canada's most popular vehicles recalled over transmission issue; 95,000 impacted
One of the country's most popular vehicles is being recalled in Canada due to a transmission issue that may impact tens of thousands of drivers.
WikiLeaks' Assange pleads guilty in deal with U.S. that secures his freedom, ends legal fight
WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange has pleaded guilty to obtaining and publishing U.S. military secrets in a deal with Justice Department prosecutors that secures his liberty and concludes a drawn-out legal saga that raised divisive questions about press freedom and national security.
'We need to regroup,' says Liberal minister and Ontario campaign co-chair in light of byelection loss
A member of Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's cabinet and the party's Ontario co-chair for the next campaign says the Liberals 'need to regroup' after a shocking overnight byelection loss to Pierre Poilievre's Conservatives.
Pre-med students can't take MCAT in Quebec because of Bill 96
Areeba Ahmed says she's always dreamed of becoming a surgeon but her road to the operating room has become a complicated one ever since Quebec's French language law came into effect.
Protesters try to topple Queen Victoria statue near pro-Palestinian encampment in Montreal
Montreal police were called to intervene after protesters attempted to tear down the Queen Victoria statue at Victoria Square.
Cup Noodles serves up notoriously poisonous pufferfish
Pufferfish is regarded as a luxury in Japan and a meal featuring the potentially poisonous delicacy can easily cost up to 20,000 yen (US$125) at high-end restaurants.
'Truly a great British Columbian': Former B.C. premier John Horgan has cancer again
Former B.C. premier and current Canadian ambassador to Germany John Horgan has been diagnosed with cancer for a third time.
New experience in Halifax gets people up close and personal to the ocean's most feared predator
Atlantic Shark Expeditions launched a new shark cage experience which gives brave attendees a chance to get up close and personal with the oceans most feared predator.