Sask. court hears arguments from province, UR Pride in pronoun law appeal
The Saskatchewan Government is in the province's highest court fighting to prevent a Court of King’s Bench judge from determining if its Parents' Bill of Rights actually violates the Charter.
In August 2023, the government announced a policy requiring students under 16 years of age to have parental permission before they change their pronouns or names in school.
LGBTQ2S+ advocates then requested and were granted a court injunction which halted the use of the policy.
In response, the Sask Party government enacted the use of the notwithstanding clause into Bill C-37, better known as the Parents’ Bill of Rights in attempt to stop the court challenge.
In February, Justice Michael Megaw ruled UR Pride should still get the chance to have the court review the law's impacts under the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
Megaw's decision would allow UR Pride and the government to present all their evidence and arguments in court, although the invocation of Section 33 of the Charter, also known as the notwithstanding clause, means a judge could not strike it down.
The government is making the case that its use of Section 33 means that since the court has no power to strike the law down, it should not be allowed to review whether the law violates the Charter.
Three Arguments
The government’s appeal relied on three main arguments:
There was an error of law for allowing the challenge to proceed, the issue is moot because of the use of the notwithstanding clause and UR Pride is abusing the judicial process.
Government counsel believed Justice Megaw made an error of law in allowing UR Pride to amend its application to include a constitutional challenge.
“Jurisdiction of the court is removed when the notwithstanding clause in invoked,” lawyer Milad Alishahi argued in court Monday. “The ability of the court completely to deal with the question [whether a law violates a charter provision] doesn’t exist.”
The province also believes the challenge is moot because of the use of the clause.
“The learning judge made an error of law in failing to find the declaration sought to find Sections 7 and 15 [of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms] raised in the issue,” said government lawyer Bennet Misskey. “To determine whether a matter is moot, it is necessary to assess what practical remedies are available to both parties.”
Court of Appeal Justice Georgina Jackson challenged Misskey’s comment.
“Would it have been better for the learn judge not to have passed on the issue of jurisdiction and focused on the issue of mootness?” she asked.
“Certainly,” Misskey replied. “Had the court found they had jurisdiction to issue some sort of declaration it was incumbent to then address the question of mootness.”
“By deferring the issue, it almost renders the question of mootness itself in a certain way,” he added.
Finally, lawyers say UR Pride is abusing the court process in trying to hold the government to account.
“It’s such a different case,” Deron Kuski said. “They are saying they want a decision that will hold the government to account.”
Kuski added he believes it is not up to the court to allow the process.
“The court should not concern itself with the issue of accountability,” he said. “Public accountability comes at the ballot box, not from the judiciary.”
UR Pride on defense
For over a year, UR Pride and multiple other advocate groups have been on the offensive in trying to halt the pronoun policies included in the Parents’ Bill of Rights.
But now, they are defending the decision to allow their connotational challenge.
“The issue of this case from day zero has been whether this law is constitutional,” said Adam Goldenberg, co-counsel for UR Pride. “I have real concerns with the suggestion its abusive and improper for a party challenging the constitutionality of a law to seek the determination whether the law is.”
“The government has taken the position the effect of section 33 is unaffected by the rights of the groups in question,” Chief Justice Robert Leurer said. “Are being asked to decide an issue on a factual pattern?”
“No one is questioning the legislative policy in this case,” Goldenberg said. “You can’t look at which rights are being overridden and whether it was a wise or unwise legislative choice.”
“As long as the full requirements are met, the law operates,” he added. “None of that is being disputed in this case.”
Goldenberg went on to submit there is a real need to inform the Saskatchewan electorate and elected officials of the provisions which the government has sought to infringe with the use of the notwithstanding clause.
“The purpose of every charter claim is ultimately to educate the legislatures who have the power to change the law of their constitutional obligations,” he said. “None of that is improper. None of that is abusive.”
Setting the precedent
The looming appeal decision stands to set the precedent for similar cases across the country.
“The court has an important role when the government chooses to violate the charter rights of young people or any part of the population,” said UR Pride co-counsel and Director of Legal for Egale Canada Bennett Jensen.
Both the provinces of New Brunswick and Alberta have enacted similar pronoun policy laws and were granted intervener status in this case.
Representatives from both provinces made submissions Monday in support of the Sask Party government’s position.
Legal battles in each province are also expected in the near future.
Sask. Minister of Justice and Attorney General Bronwyn Eyre asserted the government’s support for parental rights.
“It is important to include parents in these crucial decisions,” she told reporters at a media conference in Saskatoon Monday. “We’ve always been clear we’ll use every tool at our disposal to do that.”
“The notwithstanding clause is an integral part of the Charter of Rights [and Freedoms] and was long fought for … as a means for a balance between the legislative and judicial [branches],” Eyre added.
Jensen responded by saying it is disappointing to see the Saskatchewan government continue to defend policies he says target the province’s most vulnerable.
“When political leaders are telling young people it’s not okay to be themselves, that it’s not okay to be different at school, that has a devastating effect on young people,” he said. “The fact the policy has continued to be in effect this whole time continues to cause real harm across the population.”
More arguments in support of UR Pride’s challenge will continue Tuesday.
-With files from Rory MacLean
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
NEW With the U.S. election approaching, could American voters in Canada make a difference?
With the U.S. election widely predicted to be a close race, some believe American voters in Canada and overseas will be crucial in helping elect the new president about a month from now.
Canadian figure skater suspended at least 6 years for 'sexual maltreatment'
Canadian figure skater Nikolaj Sorensen has been suspended for at least six years for 'sexual maltreatment,' the Office of the Sport Integrity Commissioner announced Wednesday.
Grandparents found hugging each other after fallen tree killed them in their South Carolina home
As Hurricane Helene roared outside, the wind howling and branches snapping, John Savage went to his grandparents' bedroom to make sure they were OK.
W5 Investigates What it's like to interview a narco
Drug smuggling is the main industry for Mexican cartels, but migrant smuggling is turning into a financial windfall. In this fourth instalment of CTV W5's 'Narco Jungle: The Death Train,' Avery Haines is in Juarez where she speaks with one of the human smugglers known as 'coyotes.'
B.C. man ordered to pay damages for defamatory Google review
A B.C. man has been ordered to pay a total of $4,000 to a Coquitlam company and its two owners because of a negative review he posted on Google.
DEVELOPING Israel extends evacuation warnings in Lebanon, signalling a wider offensive
The Israeli military on Thursday warned people to evacuate a city and other communities in southern Lebanon that are north of a UN-declared buffer zone, signalling that it may widen a ground operation launched earlier this week against the Hezbollah militant group.
Ontario family devastated after losing thousands to online flight ticket scam
An Ontario family was planning a religious trip to Saudi Arabia that included 10 people, but when they were checking in for their flights, the family discovered some of their tickets were fake.
For Canadians seeking a non-mRNA COVID vaccine, lack of Novavax shot is 'unfair,' advocates say
The federal government's decision to not provide Novavax's COVID-19 vaccine this respiratory virus season raises health equity concerns, experts and advocates say, as some Canadians look to the U.S. to get the shot.
Albertan first Canadian veteran to compete in Mrs. Universe pageant
In less than a year, an Alberta woman has gone from gracing the stage at her first pageant to competing at the Mrs. Universe pageant in South Korea. She's making history by becoming the first Canadian veteran to compete internationally.