Sask. Court of Appeal reserves decision on pronoun law legal challenge
An appeal hearing stemming from a court challenge of the Government of Saskatchewan’s Parents’ Bill of Rights has come to a close.
The provincial government is in Saskatchewan’s highest court fighting to prevent a Court of King’s Bench judge from determining if the law actually violates the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
Lawyers representing UR Pride and supporting interveners finalized their arguments Tuesday in defense of the decision to allow their challenge to continue.
UR Pride, and its supporters, believe the court does have the ability to hear and make a decision regarding the law.
“The government is not empowered to silence the judiciary on a question of the constitutional rights,” Adam Goldenberg argued. “And make its voice the only voice in determining what is ultimately the voters’ decision whether this law should operate.”
In total, nine interveners support a decision to continue the challenge, ranging in organization from the Canadian Civil Liberties Association to the John Howard Society.
All nine organizations spoke at the hearing Tuesday.
“Section 33 [of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms] does not exempt the legislature from the application of the Charter provisions or the rights those provisions guarantee,” Goldenberg said. “[It] only exempts the legislature from the ordinary function which would otherwise render the legislation inoperable.”
“Sometimes Charter rights overlap,” said Justice Neal Caldwell. “And when we look at those rights, we look at the principle right and we don’t necessarily address the secondary or tertiary rights.”
Government reply
Before the hearing came to a close, lawyers representing the province were allowed to reply to the submissions made by UR Pride and its supporters.
“If the Section 12 hearing does go ahead, it doesn’t change the jurisdictional or mootness issue,” Malid Alishahi told the tribunal. “Mootness is not all or nothing. Some claims or actions may be moot. Others may not be.”
Alishahi went on the say UR Pride’s arguments regarding overlapping constitutional evidence is speculative.
“When the legislature invokes the notwithstanding clause, the sections that are identified are no longer applicable,” he said. “And the only question of the constitutionality is whether the government would be permitted to respond in that fashion.”
“There’s no requirement by the government to respond to a full case of a potential breach of which sections have been notwithstood,” Alishahi added.
Decision reserved
The five-judge panel reserved its decision to an unknown date as they take into account two full days of arguments.
In his closing, Chief Justice Robert Leurer thanked all sides for their well-developed submissions.
“We’ve been privileged with excellent argument by all counsel,” he said. “It’s been a privilege to hear counsel of this calibre in this court.”
Now, as they have many times over the past year, both sides now await a decision from the court.
Egale Canada Director of Legal and UR Pride co-counsel Bennett Jensen says its easy for him to be patient with the court process but understands it can be difficult for others.
“Litigation takes a long time,” he told reporters Tuesday. “As it proceeds, the harm continues.”
Jensen added the effects of this decision stretch beyond just those closely tied to the policies within the Parents’ Bill of Rights.
“The notwithstanding clause is not something that is well understood. There needs to be oversight of that function. That is what we’re arguing for,” he said.
“It’s something that should be concerning for all Canadians because all of us benefit from Charter protections every day.”
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
2 Canadians killed in Lebanon, Global Affairs Canada confirms amid Israel-Hezbollah conflict
Two Canadians are among those killed in southern Lebanon, Global Affairs Canada confirmed late Tuesday. While GAC has not confirmed their names due to privacy, family members tell CTV News the two people killed are Hussein and Daad Tabaja.
EXCLUSIVE Image released of mysterious object shot down over Yukon in 2023
An image of the unidentified object shot down over Canada's Yukon territory in February 2023 has been obtained by CTVNews.ca.
Debate gets testy as MPs consider confidence motion in PM Trudeau
MPs debated the first non-confidence motion of the fall House of Commons sitting today, seeing Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre push once again for a snap election. But with votes secured to keep them afloat, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's Liberals were quick to turn the discussion into a referendum on the Conservative alternative.
B.C. councillor blames 'leftist extremists' after blackface photo surfaces online
A city councillor in British Columbia says an online mob of "extremists" and "politically motivated hackers" is responsible for uncovering and publicizing a photo of him wearing a blackface costume to a Halloween party in 2007.
Feds have 'no intention' of pausing next carbon tax increase, Guilbeault says
The federal government has 'no intention' of pausing the next planned increase to the carbon price, Environment Minister Steven Guilbeault confirms.
'It shows how out of touch the Premier is': Reaction to Doug Ford's encampment comments
After Ontario Premier Doug Ford made controversial comments about solutions to get people out of homeless encampments, advocates and members of the opposition spoke up on Tuesday.
Ont. driver rescues abandoned puppies found in ditch
Four puppies were found near County Road 21 in Essa Township after a passerby spotted one when it ran out of the ditch and onto the road.
Couple in Sault Ste. Marie, Ont., awarded more than $500K for enduring life with hellish neighbour
We've all had neighbours we didn't like, but two people from Sault Ste. Marie have been awarded more than half a million dollars for the 'extreme' behaviour of the people who lived next to them.
Missouri executes Marcellus Williams for 1998 killing of a woman despite her family's calls to spare his life
A Missouri man convicted of breaking into a woman’s home and repeatedly stabbing her was executed Tuesday over the objections of the victim’s family and the prosecutor, who wanted the death sentence commuted to life in prison.