Sask. pronoun policy: Judge to hear arguments in injunction application
A hearing for the injunction application filed against the Government of Saskatchewan’s parental inclusion and consent policy is scheduled for Tuesday morning at Regina’s Court of King’s Bench.
UR Pride, co-represented by Egale Canada and McCarthy Tétrault LLP, is challenging the constitutionality of the new policy, which requires teachers to obtain parental consent for any student under the age of 16 to change their preferred name or pronouns in school.
Adam Goldenberg, a partner with McCarthy Tétrault and co-representative for UR Pride, argues the new policy discriminates against gender-diverse children, and forces teachers to misgender students and potentially “out” kids to their parents.
“Expert evidence that we’ve filed shows that that is harmful and that causes permanent, irreparable harm to students to deny them that safe, respectful and accepting interaction with a trusted adult in the school learning environment,” Goldenberg said.
UR Pride’s main argument centres on what it believes are violations of two sections in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
According to Goldenberg, the policy violates Section 7 and Section 15, which relate to personal security and equality, respectively.
UR Pride’s legal representatives are seeking an injunction that would prevent the policy from being implemented until a judge can decide if the policy is constitutional.
“If a policy could be unconstitutional and it’s going to inflict irreparable harm on Canadians, in this case, young, gender diverse students in Saskatchewan schools, then the policy should not go enforce and that harm should not be suffered while we figure out if it’s lawful or not,” Goldenberg said.
Late last week, Saskatchewan’s Advocate for Children and Youth released her findings after a review of the policy.
“Gender identity is a prohibited ground of discrimination under provincial human rights legislation, and the education system has a duty to accommodate the needs of transgender and gender diverse students,” said advocate Dr. Lisa Broda in a press release.
Broda acknowledged that children have a fundamental right to parental support and guidance, but said children’s other rights, including gender identity and freedom of expression, must not be hindered in the process.
Broda agreed with the government’s desire to place a high importance on parent’s involvement in education. However, she said that can be achieved without strict rules around consent, which could result in a violation of children’s human rights.
The advocate made two recommendations, including a policy amendment that would recognize children’s rights to gender identity and expression, remove ambiguities around the scope of the policy and respect the preferred names and pronouns of students able to demonstrate the capacity to make personal decisions.
Broda also recommended the Ministry of Education develop a concrete plan to increase supports to help facilitate parental inclusion when in the best interests of the child.
CTV News reached out to Broda for further comment, but she was not immediately available.
Following the advocate’s report, the Ministry of Education said it acknowledges the comments and agrees that there are “various positive impacts derived from the policy, such as recognizing the importance of parents and guardians in supporting a child’s development.”
“The Government of Saskatchewan remains committed to protecting the right of parents to be involved in their children's education and to implementation of the Parental Inclusion and Consent policy,” a statement read.
Premier Scott Moe has previously stated his government plans to introduce the policy as legislation in the upcoming fall session and will use every tool available, which could include the notwithstanding clause, to protect parental rights.
The court hearing is scheduled for 10 a.m. Tuesday.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories

NEW 'I'm in no way ashamed of my infertility': The challenge for families trying to conceive without coverage
Families that need help conceiving a child are met with financial burdens that should be covered through government health care and insurance, advocates say.
Fatal stabbing of German tourist by suspected radical puts sharp focus on Paris Olympics
A bloodstain by a bridge over the Seine river was the only remaining sign on Sunday of a fatal knife attack 12 hours earlier on a German tourist, allegedly carried out by a young man under watch for suspected Islamic radicalization.
Teen girls are being victimized by deepfake nudes. One family is pushing for more protections
A mother and her 14-year-old daughter are advocating for better protections for victims after AI-generated nude images of the teen and other female classmates were circulated at a high school in New Jersey.
1 person is dead and 11 missing after a landslide and flash floods hit Indonesia's Sumatra island
Rescuers recovered the body of a man buried under tons of mud and rocks from flash floods and a landslide that crashed onto a hilly village on Indonesia's Sumatra island. Officials said Sunday that 11 people are still missing.
Strong earthquake that sparked a tsunami warning leaves 1 dead amid widespread panic in Philippines
A powerful earthquake that shook the southern Philippines killed at least one villager and injured several others as thousands scrambled out of their homes in panic and jammed roads to higher grounds after a tsunami warning was issued, officials said Sunday.
Israel orders more people in crowded southern Gaza to evacuate as heavy bombardment shifts there
Israel's military ordered more areas in and around Gaza's second-largest city of Khan Younis to evacuate on Sunday, followed by heavy bombardment, as it shifted its offensive to the southern half of the territory where it asserts that leaders of the Hamas militant group are hiding.
Naloxone: What to know about the opioid overdose-reversing drug, free across Canada
Health Canada has called the opioid crisis one of the most serious public health threats in recent history, and an addictions specialist says everyone can play a part in helping reduce the death toll. All it takes is access to naloxone, a life-saving medication that temporarily reverses an opioid overdose.
'My door is always open': heritage minister insists feds working hard 'to bring Meta back to the table' on C-18
Canada's heritage minister insists the federal government is still working to get Facebook and Instagram parent company Meta back to the bargaining table to negotiate a deal to compensate Canadian news organizations as part of the regulatory process for the controversial Online News Act.
Bonnie Crombie wins Ontario Liberal leadership after 3 rounds of voting
Ontario Liberals have selected Bonnie Crombie, a three-term big city mayor and former MP who boasts that she gets under the skin of Premier Doug Ford, as their next leader to go head to head with the premier in the next provincial election.