Sask. sexual assault trial stayed after more than 850 days of 'excessive delay'
The sexual assault trial of a Saskatchewan man has been stayed after a judge found the accused’s right to a trial within a reasonable time was violated.
Based on a decision from Justice James Rybchuk dated on April 1, the accused was charged with one count of sexual assault on Oct. 25, 2021.
The case was originally scheduled to go to trial in late June 2023, the judge determining the original time frame accounted for 517 days of delays, with time deducted for delays caused by the defence.
“This is within the normal period of time that it takes for a matter of this nature to reach trial and therefore would not have constituted a violation of [the accused’s] Charter rights had the trial proceeded as scheduled that day,” Rybchuk said.
However, that time frame was compromised when the judge accounted for another 342 days between June 29, 2023, and June 4, 2024, the anticipated end of a rescheduled trial.
In total, the judge determined the case was effectively delayed for 859 days, with time deducted for moves of the defence.
“I have determined that the net delay in this case exceeds the presumptive ceiling of 18 months, the delay is presumptively unreasonable,” Rybchuk said. “The onus is therefore on the Crown to rebut this presumption based on the presence of exceptional circumstances.”
The decision is response to an application made in January, when lawyers representing the accused moved forward on an application for a judicial stay of proceeding.
Rybchuk would rule that the “presumptively unreasonable delay cannot be justified based on exceptional circumstances”, forcing the stay forward.
“Excessive delay caused [the accused’s] future to hang in the balance for more than two years while he attended over twenty court appearances and anxiously awaited trial. Excessive delay caused the complainant to sit on the sidelines awaiting her opportunity to seek vindication for the harm allegedly inflicted upon her while the case languished in court,” Rybchuk said.
"Ultimately, a potentially meritorious sexual assault allegation was discarded.”
Rybchuk also noted the use of “considerable judicial resources” needed to respond to the initial allegation and the “mountain of evidence and materials filed by counsel”.
“The unfortunate reality is that this trial could have proceeded were it not for the delay caused by all the pretrial applications and motions,” Rybchuk said in closing. “As demonstrated in this case, delayed justice is justice denied. And there is nothing just about that.”
The trial was scheduled to occur June 3 and 4.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Teen was doing homework at family's Mississauga, Ont. restaurant when gunman opened fire: testimony
The 13-year-old sister of a young man killed in the attack on her family’s Mississauga restaurant in 2021 took the stand in a Brampton courthouse on Monday to describe the terrifying moments of coming under fire.
'Repetitive partisan conduct': Conservatives to force vote on ousting Speaker Greg Fergus
The federal Conservatives have advanced a motion that will force MPs to vote on whether to oust Greg Fergus as House of Commons Speaker, after MPs' deputy adjudicator ruled Monday that the Liberal member's allegedly errant partisan event invite required urgent attention.
Trial for B.C. man accused of killing, dismembering wife begins
The trial for a Langley man accused of killing his wife began Monday, with the prosecutor laying out a disturbing series of facts agreed upon by both Crown and defence.
Henrique to play in Game 3 of Western Conference final; Hintz a game-time decision
Adam Henrique is set to join the action. Roope Hintz might be doing the same.
What a CBSA strike could look like, according to an expert
Slowed or interrupted travel, the passing of goods and significantly restricted borders should be expected if Canadian border workers take upcoming strike action.
WATCH Alta. man rescues wild foal trapped on steep cliffside
A man's daring rescue of a newborn wild foal that was trapped after falling down a steep embankment was caught on video over the weekend.
Severe thunderstorms, tornado watch in some areas of Canada. Here's where
Depending on where you live, you can expect to get a mixed bag of weather this week, as local forecasts predict heavy rain, strong wind, severe thunderstorms and even snowfall across some areas of Canada.
B.C. senior prepares to move due to devastating effects of fraud
A Courtenay, B.C., senior is downsizing and packing to move as she comes to accept she can no longer afford to stay in her home, after falling victim to a scam that robbed her of her life savings worth more than $100,000.
Israel close to approving Gaza reunification program before Rafah invasion: Miller
Immigration Minister Marc Miller says Israel seemed to be on the verge of approving a program to get Palestinian relatives of Canadians out of the Gaza Strip before the country's invasion of the town of Rafah.