Supreme Court of Canada reserves decision in case of Sask. jail policy
The Justices of Canada’s Supreme Court are deliberating a case brought forward by the John Howard Society of Saskatchewan, challenging practices by the province’s correctional system.
As the final day of proceedings wrapped up, one topic spoken to at length was the severity of offences and how they correlate with the severity of punishment.
Currently, these factors are left at the discretion of corrections officers on duty. When inmates are accused of an offence – it only needs to be proven more likely than not before action can be taken.
This standard, used by provincially run correctional institutions in Saskatchewan, is known as "balance of probabilities." It differs greatly from the standards used by Correctional Services Canada.
Federal penitentiaries require proof “beyond a reasonable doubt” that infractions occurred in order for disciplinary actions can be taken.
The defence argued that treating every individual disciplinary infraction the same as a criminal trial would negatively affect order within facilities and put a further burden on inmates.
“If these hearings were to become criminal trials, then there may actually be a greater impact on the inmates … then dealing with it quickly, swiftly and informally,” argued Crown Counsel Katherine Roy in her closing remarks.
Now that final arguments have been made, the decision will be reserved, meaning the judges will be taking some time to consider the matter before delivering the decision at a later date.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
DEVELOPING Live updates: Hurricane Milton makes landfall in Florida
The 'extremely dangerous Category 3 hurricane' has made landfall near Siesta Key, Fla., according to the U.S. National Hurricane Center.
Hundreds of thousands of popular vehicles recalled in Canada over steering issue
Hundreds of thousands of vehicles are being recalled in Canada due to a steering-related issue that could increase a driver's risk of crash.
'We want things to go forward': Bloc leader hints his party 'might' help end House impasse
The leader of the Bloc Quebecois says his party 'might play a role' in helping the Liberals get House of Commons business rolling again — after days of Conservative-led debate on a privilege matter — but that his assistance would come at a cost.
video Why are there cars in the Detroit River?
Dozens of cars were pulled out of the Detroit River in west Windsor on Tuesday, causing many questions for Windsorites.
Washington state woman calls 911 after being hounded by up to 100 raccoons
Sheriff's deputies in Washington's Kitsap County frequently get calls about animals -- loose livestock, problem dogs. But the 911 call they received recently from a woman being hounded by dozens of raccoons swarming her home near Poulsbo stood out.
Pilot dies aboard Turkish Airlines flight, forcing emergency landing in New York
A Turkish Airlines jetliner headed from Seattle to Istanbul made an emergency landing in New York on Wednesday after the captain died on board, an airline official said.
Former CIA director says Israel 'unlikely' to target Iranian nuclear sites as retaliation
Former CIA Director and retired Gen. David Petraeus says it is 'unlikely' Israel will target Iranian nuclear sites in retaliation for last week's ballistic missile attack.
Rare Monet returned to family more than 80 years after it was stolen by Nazis
A Claude Monet pastel painting stolen by Nazis during World War II, which vanished for decades only to show up with a Louisiana art dealer, was returned Wednesday in New Orleans to the descendants of its original owners.
Women say they were kicked off of Spirit Airlines flight for what they were wearing
Two Orange County women are speaking out after they say they were kicked off of a Spirit Airlines flight because of what they were wearing.