Sask. Child Advocate: Pronoun policy could run contrary to human rights laws, needs changes
The Saskatchewan Child Advocate says the provincial government's new policy regarding the use of different pronouns in schools could violate human rights.
Child Advocate Lisa Broda announced the review in August, shortly after the announcement of a new policy requiring students under 16 years old to seek parental consent before changing their pronouns or preferred first names in a school setting.
In a news release announcing the results of her review, Broda said such strict rules around consent "could result in a violation of a young person's rights under provincial, constitutional, and international human rights laws."
While the advocate's office says the recognition that youth over the age of 16 can provide their own consent is positive, Broda found the emphasis on age is not justifiable.
“Many young people under the age of 16 will have the capacity to make this type of decision. Giving them the chance to demonstrate capacity is an important step in accommodating their right to their gender identity,” said Broda.
While the advocate agreed that parental or guardian inclusion in schools is essential to creating an environment that serves the children’s best interest, Broda also recognized the rights of the child.
“It is critical that this be understood from a child rights perspective,” the report says. “Children are human beings with their own rights and legally recognized ability to make certain personal decisions in accordance with their maturity and capacity.”
The report references the mature minor doctrine. In 2009 the Supreme Court of Canada confirmed the doctrine as the standard to apply when youth want to make independent decisions.
The report defines gender identity as existing on a spectrum of masculine, feminine, non-binary, or anything in between, or “who you know yourself to be,” noting that gender diversity is part of the human condition, with people challenging binary understandings of gender throughout history.
Transgender and gender-diverse youth are vulnerable, the report says, and continue to face stigmatization and fear.
“The duress from not having one’s gender identity and expression respected is what leads to individuals experiencing adverse mental health problems such as anxiety, depression, and suicidality,” the report says.
The report references the Saskatchewan Human Rights Code, with sections two and 13 guaranteeing that children and youth have the right to education without discrimination, noting that “misgendering” is a form of discrimination.
The report also states that not letting teachers and other school staff to use preferred names and pronouns of students without prior consent from their parent or guardian is also a violation of their rights under the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child.
Broda also expressed concern that the policy could put further pressure on existing school supports.
“In 2022, the Government of Saskatchewan accepted our recommendation to increase the presence of mental health supports in schools, however indicated that work would not begin on the implementation of this recommendation until 2026," Broda said.
"It is unclear to our office how the education system will provide sufficient support in situations where a student is negatively affected by this policy."
Broda's review makes offers a pair of recommendations.
The first asks the Saskatchewan government to amend the policy to "recognize the right of all individuals to non-discrimination on the basis of gender identity and expression, to "remove ambiguities" around the policy's scope and to respect "the preferred name and pronouns of students able to demonstrate the capacity to make personal decisions."
The second recommendation asks the Ministry of Education to "develop and implement a concrete plan to increase the professional supports available in schools to facilitate parental inclusion when in the best interests of the child."
The advocate's office says the findings of the review have been shared with the ministry.
Premier Scott Moe has signalled his government plans to enshrine the policy in law and that he's willing to turn to the notwithstanding clause to stave off potential Charter challenges.
The policy is currently subject to a legal challenge by a University of Regina-based pride organization and Egale Canada.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Cisco reveals security breach, warns of state-sponsored spy campaign
State-sponsored actors targeted security devices used by governments around the world, according to technology firm Cisco Systems, which said the network devices are coveted intrusion points by spies.
An emergency slide falls off a Delta Air Lines plane, forcing pilots to return to JFK in New York
An emergency slide fell off a Delta Air Lines jetliner shortly after takeoff Friday from New York, and pilots who felt a vibration in the plane circled back to land safely at JFK Airport.
Last letters of pioneering climber who died on Everest reveal dark side of mountaineering
George Mallory is renowned for being one of the first British mountaineers to attempt to scale the dizzying heights of Mount Everest during the 1920s. Nearly a century later, newly digitized letters shed light on Mallory’s hopes and fears about ascending Everest.
Decoy bear used to catch man who illegally killed a grizzly, B.C. conservation officers say
A man has been handed a lengthy hunting ban and fined thousands of dollars for illegally killing a grizzly bear, B.C. conservation officers say.
opinion RFK Jr.'s presidential candidacy and its potential threat to Biden and Trump
Although it's still unclear how much damage Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s candidacy can do to either Joe Biden or Donald Trump this election, Washington political columnist Eric Ham says what is clear is both sides recognize the potential threat.
Haida elder suing Catholic Church and priest, hopes for 'healing and reconciliation'
The lawyer for a residential school survivor leading a proposed class-action defamation lawsuit against the Catholic Church over residential schools says the court action is a last resort.
First court appearance for boy and girl charged in death of Halifax 16-year-old
A girl and a boy, both 14 years old, made their first appearance today in a Halifax courtroom, where they each face a second-degree murder charge in the stabbing death of a 16-year-old high school student.
Opinion I just don't get Taylor Swift
It's one thing to say you like Taylor Swift and her music, but don't blame CNN's AJ Willingham's when she says she just 'doesn't get' the global phenomenon.
It's 30 years since apartheid ended. South Africa's celebrations are set against growing discontent
South Africa marked 30 years since the end of apartheid and the birth of its democracy with a ceremony in the capital Saturday that included a 21-gun salute and the waving of the nation's multicolored flag.